Guide · Updated
Bin Stores vs. Thrift Stores vs. Outlet Stores
Short answer
Bin stores sell purchased liquidation pallets of returns and overstock at a flat, decreasing price; thrift stores sell donated secondhand goods, usually priced per item; and outlet stores sell a retailer's own overstock or factory seconds at a fixed discount off original retail: three genuinely different sourcing and pricing models that happen to share a discount-shopping reputation.
| Bin store | Goodwill Outlet | Thrift store | Outlet store | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Inventory source | Purchased liquidation pallets (returns, overstock, shelf-pulls) | Donated goods that didn't sell in Goodwill's regular shops | Donated secondhand goods | A specific retailer's own overstock or factory seconds |
| Pricing model | Flat price per section, decreasing through the week | Usually by the pound, sometimes a flat price per item | Per-item, set by the store | Fixed discount off original retail |
| Condition | New, open-box, and used, mixed together, untested | Used, unsorted, untested | Used, donated condition | New, but often irregular or out-of-season |
| Ownership | Independent small businesses | Local Goodwill nonprofits | Often a nonprofit or charity | Usually operated by the original retailer or brand |
| Returns | Almost always all sales final | All sales final | Varies, often final sale | Usually the retailer's standard return policy applies |
Why Do People Confuse These Three Store Types?
All three involve digging through discounted goods, and Goodwill's own "Bins" locations (sometimes called Goodwill Outlets) use a bin-based, per-pound model that looks and feels a lot like an Amazon bin store on the surface. The difference that actually matters is where the inventory comes from: donation versus purchased liquidation. That's what drives everything else: pricing model, condition range, and what a "sale" even means at each type of store.
Because shoppers looking for a bin store often want a Goodwill Outlet too, our directory lists 36 of them, each labelled "Goodwill Outlet" on its state page so you can tell them apart from bin stores. Regular Goodwill shops are not listed.
Which Store Type Should You Choose?
If you specifically want returned and overstock retail merchandise, including sealed new items, a bin store is the right format. See what you'll actually find there. If you're after secondhand clothing and household goods at the lowest possible price, a thrift store or Goodwill outlet is usually the better fit. Outlet stores are the right choice when you want a specific brand's products with a normal return policy, just at a discount.
Browse Amazon bin stores in your state to see what's actually available near you.
Questions people ask
Which is cheaper, a bin store or a thrift store?
It depends on the item. Bin stores tend to beat thrift stores on newer electronics and sealed goods; thrift stores can beat bin stores on used clothing and household items priced individually rather than by a flat bin rate.
Is a Goodwill Outlet the same as an Amazon bin store?
No, though the "dig through a bin" shopping mechanic is similar. A Goodwill Outlet sells donated secondhand goods, usually by weight; an Amazon bin store sells purchased liquidation pallets of returns and overstock, usually by the item.
Read next
- Common Bin Store Names, Explained
The naming patterns bin stores actually use, so you know what to search for.
- How We Verify This Directory
The actual process behind every listing: what we check, what we show, and what we don’t claim.
- What Is a Bin Store?
What bin stores actually are, where the inventory comes from, and how they differ from ordinary retail.